Sunday, 14 September 2014

The Death of the Book



As we usher in a new age that is digitally saturated to the point of being almost digitally reliant one might wonder if it would be too bold to regard to the book as a piece of redundant literacy technology. I would argue that this is a reality of a non-too distant where the "book” is used in the past tense, that we are beginning to see the end of the book if you will. The book was once a form of writing that once dominated the way humans engaged with the world shaped by written text. From children’s books to academic journals the form of the book was once the standardised way we packaged and presented collections of written text. However, this is all currently under threat as there is a perception that books have now been replaced by screens. I would argue that this comparison isn't fair or entirely accurate. It is of my opinion that a more accurate way to view the recent shift in writing and reading practices due to writing technologies would be to view books as being replaced by webpages. By doing so, one could in turn regard websites as the new "books" and the portable screens that have been integrated into our lives as something entirely new. Ultimately these new devices have become necessary apparatuses that come in the form of laptops, tablets and smartphones to give us access to the new generations “public library” that is the internet. To elaborate on this point I want to discuss the early stages of how digital writing when compared to the book. I will then discuss how web based writing has, in the recent years, come to really become viable as the "book’s successor. As well as this I will also discuss how web based writing has inherent unique functions that have had such an impact on the way we engage with the textual world that to return to older textual rituals would be foolish when realizing it's potential as a piece of writing technology. 



I thought I would start off with a video clip I was shown in my first year of university. It is a clip that imitates the format conventionally used to introduce the viewer to what could be an innovative piece of technology. It takes on a very infomercial-esque form to explain the features of the “book” as something entirely new and cutting edge. It must be noted that during the time of this video’s making web based writing would have been entering the second stage of what Dennis Baron[1] explains as a necessary and inevitable cycle that all literacy technologies undergo. During the second stage Baron explains that new literacy technologies, after being introduced by early adopters, will first begin to be incorporated in a way to mimic the functions of older and more established writing technologies.






This video clip was made by an online bookstore justifying the book as a medium that was at that time superior in many ways to its still then undeveloped successors. Although these new media devices were not yet developed technologically, accessible, or widely enough adopted to truly challenge the book in its then current state the bookseller site might still have seen the book as being dethroned in the future by these devices. In fact Sam Harris in 2011 posted about the struggles as an author of traditional printed texts adapting to the web based textual world and the growing associated audience. This is an audience who had come to expect information and ideas to be presented in a much more condensed manner, as well as for Free. His post can be read here[3] and is an insightful look from an industry insider who recognized the vast differences between publishing writing in traditional forms versus in the new web based means as well as its differing audiences and changed his writing practices accordingly. 




What I would like to do is discuss the how portable digital reading and writing technologies have developed to the point where they have begun to meet the necessary requirements of competently mimicking and fulfilling the functions provided by the book by discussing some of the showcased functions of the book from the video and how these advantages of the book have matched by advances in technologies below:
A Book requires no electricity and power.
This point refers to the way in which electronic devices such as eBook readers, laptops, tablets and smartphones are only as useful as their battery life determines on a single charge. As these technologies were in their earliest stages of technological development these were surely problem. In recent years though there has been a leap in technological advancement in low voltage processors, larger capacity batteries that are more compact as well energy efficient screens which have increased the amount of productivity that can be achieved through these web capable devices on a single charge (Insert link on tablet battery life.)

Books are small and portable.
The second point refers to the fact that books are compact. In theory webpages don't take up any physical space and are determined by the internet capable media devices that are used to access websites and eBooks. New media devices though now in come in a variety of forms. There is even a rising trend of what is described as the "phablet"[4] with the demand for smartphones with larger screens that are approaching tablet size territory to blur the line between a screen big enough to be productive and portability. As well as this tablets now come in a standard array of size variants such as Apple and Google both offering both a ten inch and seven inch variants of their popular iPad[5] and Nexus[6] tablets that have seemed to trim down form factors with each annual refresh of their product lines by shedding weight and thicknesses without compromise to performance.



In respects to the current writing landscape that is digitally/web based I would argue that through advancements in technologies digitally web based writing has developed to the point of finally being considered as a viable alternative to replace the book. This is due to the web digital writing moving away from simply mimicry to come into its own as a literacy technology with its own unique functions and is at the same time widely adopted by society. This second half will be based on discussing how the current state of the new web based writing technologies has created entirely new functions not permitted by the book.




A new kind of intertextuality
the hyperlink, something that at surface level appears to be an extension of previous reference systems synonymous with printed writing and the book. The unique web function of the hyperlink allows for several instant links to external references to be embedded into the text. These hyperlinks can then be opened up in separate tabs simultaneously with the source text. In a way this has for some people changed what can be described as the flow of reading. Traditional writing technologies such as the book are linear by nature as someone reading a book written in English may simply read left to right and top to bottom. Hyperlinks on the other hand has affected the flow of reading by fleshing it out into a multifaceted consumption ritual with hyperlinks that can be instantly opened up parallel to the source text to be juggled by the reader rather than an afterthought for further rendering. Hyperlinks though are not the exclusive type of link that can be imbedded into a web based text as the medium. Web based writing allows for another particular advantage in the ability to hybridise traditional means of writing of the alphanumeric system with other types of communication. As internet progresses in speed due to advances in fibre and smart devices become more affordable and widely adopted web based communication has evolved to become more of a multifaceted form of engagement as a hybridised form with images, videos, and audio. There is however one other function of the hyperlink, that is, hyperlinks allow for experiences of web surfing as a kind of “digital Détournement". I propose that the hyperlink allows us to move through the internet and explore the unfamiliar just as much situationists who once drifted around the city without intention as discussed by Goldsmith[7]. A great website for these kinds of experiences is Wikipedia[8] where it seems that people, myself included, have embarked on journeys of random tangents from the information that originally bought us to the site through a chain of unplanned hyperlinks of interest.




The dynamic nature of web based writing as both a blessing and a curse. 

Web based writing differs from traditional methods of writing in that it inherently doesn’t have a physical form, instead writing is transcribed as code to be retrieved via web capable devices that transform it into familiar images, symbols videos and audio. In turn this means that web based writing doesn't take a singular form as the experience differs across the platform of choice, whether it be viewing a website from a smartphone optimized format or one stripped of its advertisement through an adblocker. This inconsistency of the experience of interaction with web based writing extends further when temporality is taken into consideration. Unlike printed books that are generally printed in bulk to maintain consistency as defined editions or revised editions that are clearly defined web based writing is subject to change by the author or contributors on sites such as Wikipedia. The internet is dynamic by nature and although this is seen as an advantage in the case of a quick painless process of editing to correct errors the nature of this piece of writing technology also entails that dead links are part of the package. This is because webpages can be moved, deleted or edited without warning. To help address this problem I draw on functions of previous writing technologies such as the book and propose that a combination of hyperlinks and traditional means of referencing, although more time consuming, may be a way to inject longevity into web based writing as a complete experience with relevant search terms to make up for dead links. The idea is that with footnotes indicating the title of the webpage accompanying each hyperlink the reader is at least given guiding search terms for internet search engines such as google to find copies of the original text should a linked to webpage be deleted, moved or edited drastically.





Web based writing as having a democratising effect on knowledge and ideas
in general I would argue that web based free content is based off three types of approaches to make it financially viable. There are mandatory subscriptions and donations which are two models that maintain service through direct payment by the audience/viewer. The third is one I have previously described here[10] as a hybrid of the traditional broadcast television model as well as new methods only available via the internet. It is also the dominant model for freely available websites in that web users essentially "pay" with their time and personal information. This common commercial model guarantees free access to content to be consumed by people as well as help nurture a generation that has transitioned from passive readers and consumers of text to become active users and content creators. The web has not only democratised knowledge but also writing as well. It would seem rather inconceivable fifteen years ago to be able to find an audience for ones writing without a publishing deal. This is because for traditional writing that was primarily contained in book format would only able to be distributed to an audience via a publisher. These entities would access work on its potential to financially sound as an investment before being published. During this era one could imagine that there may have been manuscripts floating around that were rejected and failed to ever reach a reciprocal audience. With the web based age we live in now one doesn’t have to look far to find virtual spaces to publish their writing for free. In a sense this shift has made writing more interactive as once passive readers become “users” able to produce content of their own to find an audience rather than being approved by a publisher to have for a theoretical audience. This push of the user has also facilitated new forms of interaction by the reader/viewer by engaging with comments, parodies, remixes, appropriations of viewed work. The rise of the user over the passive reader is one of the functions of the web based writing age we now live in. If your country[11] permits it, web based writing can ultimately have a democratising effect on knowledge as well as ideas. The ability to comment and respond, the ability to share views, thoughts, opinions and theories with to a global audience is a defining and unique function of the internet.



Ultimately the death of the book is near upon us due to the advancements in technology in new media devices which have developed to the point where the functions of the book are not only being competently replicated but being improved on. As well as this these new media devices are being adopted as a standard way of life as the expectation to stay connected to the new age “library” that is the internet grows. Finally, the unique functions of web based writing are being realised and integrated into standard practices of reading and writing in a way that has changed the way we interact with the world as well as how we expect to be able to interact with the world. 





Done with this article? Check out this[12] one to see if you are getting the most out of your web browsing experience. 





[1] Brown, Dennis. From pencils to pixels: The Stages of Literacy Technology
[2] Popularlibros.com - Did you know the BOOK? English subtitles

[3] Harris, Sam. The Future of the Book
[4] Elgan, Mike. Rise of the’Phablet’
[5] Apple. iPad comparison
[6] Googlge. Nexus devices
[7] Goldsmith, Kenneth. Uncreative Writing.pg 37
[8] Wikipedia.org
[9]  Memeblender.com.  Meme comic - Wikipedia
[10] Ho, Edmund. What is television now?
[11] Wikipedia. Golden Shield Project
[12] Ho, Edmund. Surf the web like a “Boss”

No comments:

Post a Comment